Home » Articles and Columns, COLUMN: Scott G - Music Critics Must Die

Music Critics Must Die: PR Overkill

by Scott G - The G-Man
published Sun, 16 Nov 2008 – 17:35:52 -0800 PST
No Comment
Email this Page Share this Page Feedback

COLUMN: Artists need publicity, public relations, media management, hype, hoopla, and buzz. In every major city can be found oodles of failed screenwriters, unpublished novelists, unsung musicians, and nameless poets who call themselves PR specialists. Does that sound unfair? Remember, I’m one of them. Sure, I’ve actually gotten a screenplay produced, two books published, and 8 albums released, but always under names other than John Scott G or Scott G, so I still fit into that category.

Let’s face facts: to a certain extent we’re flacks, hypemeisters and blurb mongers. Yet so much of what gets published and posted begins with our work. Simple press releases and media announcements serve as the calling card for new works in almost every segment of commerce. In many cases, our releases are run word for word.

So, be careful who you select for your creating and disseminating your media announcements. The wrong words can determine the success or failure of your current efforts.

Recently, I received a link to information about an artist I will call Robin Battler (the name has been changed because my beef is with the artist’s publicity people; the artist may be great and undeserving of poor PR). Actually, the way it was presented was “Award Winning Artist Robin Battler.”

Okay, right away I’ve got a problem. If an award means anything, then mention it by name, as in “Grammy Winning Artist” or “Oscar Winning Artist.” Whenever someone is described as “award winning” I immediately think fondly of Victor Spinetti petulantly stating “I won an award” in “A Hard Day’s Night.”

Considering what came next, the “award winning” hype was a drop in the ocean. This is the opening paragraph of this artist’s online presentation:

“Robin’s dynamic vocals and honest lyrics have been compared to John Mayer, Tom Petty and Peter Gabriel. His sound has been described as reminiscent of George Martin’s arrangements with strings and textural guitars — a bit British meets old school with contemporary and clever lyrics. His songwriting comes from a Dylan-esque ‘fly on the wall’ storytelling perspective — the way he views the world. ‘Even when a song seems to be on the surface “about a girl” often times that girl is a metaphor for something deeper and larger in scope,’ shares Robin.”

Hysterical!

Allow me to retort: “Even when hype seems to be on the surface ‘a bunch of bullshit,’ often times that bullshit is a metaphor for something deeper and larger in scope,” shares Scott.

Technorati Tags: , , , , , ,
SPHERE: Related Content — CLICK HERE to See What Else is Out There!

About The Author / Editor:


John 'Scott' G is a partner in Golosio Music Publishing (www.golosio.com) and owns the related firms G-Man Marketing, G-Man Music, FookMovie, and SongsAndSoundtracks. His albums, recorded under the name 'The G-Man,' are on iTunes. © John Scott G and Music Industry Newswire. UNAUTHORIZED RE-PUBLICATION OF THIS CONTENT IS PROHIBITED UNDER U.S. AND INTERNATIONAL COPYRIGHT LAW EXCEPT FOR QUOTING IN CONTEXT OF ANOTHER ARTICLE OR A SHORT SUMMARY LINKING TO THIS FULL STORY.

  delicious:Music Critics Must Die: PR Overkill digg:Music Critics Must Die: PR Overkill newsvine:Music Critics Must Die: PR Overkill furl:Music Critics Must Die: PR Overkill reddit:Music Critics Must Die: PR Overkill Y!:Music Critics Must Die: PR Overkill  Add to Mixx! 
Permalink:   http://musicindustrynewswire.com/2008/11/16/min743_173552.php

Related Stories:


What’s Wrong With Music Journalism?
Music Critics Must Die: Taking the Maxim Magazine Approach to the Max
Music Critics Must Die: Grammy Whammy
Toontrack Music announces the release of the Funkmasters EZX
The Sound of No Music
Davison/Coleman Blend Folk and Classical

Rings With Side Stones


Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam. All comments are moderated and self-promotional posts will never be visible.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.